If you’ve played enough of MLB The Show 25, you already know how intense those late-inning situations can get. Whether it’s bottom of the ninth, bases loaded, or an extra-innings nail-biter, having the right strategies can make the difference between walking off with a win or suffering a crushing loss. Below are 10 clutch strategy guides to help you outsmart your opponents and keep your cool in the most critical moments.

1. Master Pitch Sequencing

Throwing the same pitch over and over may work in lower ranks, but seasoned players will pick up on patterns quickly. Mix your speeds, locations, and pitch types to keep hitters guessing. Think like a real-life pitcher and set up that nasty slider with a high heater.

2. Use Pinch Hitters Wisely

In tight games, don’t hesitate to sub in a power bat against a tough righty or lefty. But remember, it’s not just about overall rating—check individual splits. Some budget hitters can mash in the right situation.

3. Know Your Bullpen Roles

Every reliever on your squad should have a specific purpose. Set up your bullpen to have long relievers, lefty specialists, and closers. Always warm up your relievers a couple of innings ahead—panic warming a cold arm mid-inning can lead to disaster.

4. Take Advantage of Defensive Shifts

Check the batter’s tendencies before each pitch. Use defensive shifts manually or toggle auto-shift depending on your play style. A well-placed infield can stop a rally before it starts.

5. Control the Running Game

Clutch moments aren’t just about hitting. Control baserunners with quick pickoff attempts and varied delivery times. Especially when facing speedsters, paying attention to lead size and counts can prevent stolen base threats.

6. Work the Count at the Plate

It’s tempting to swing early when the pressure’s on, but taking a few pitches can lead to walks or better pitches to hit. Clutch hitting often starts with a disciplined approach. Patience can win at-bats—and games.

7. Use Quick Menus for Defensive Subs

Late in the game, don’t forget about your bench. Bringing in a defensive replacement can be the difference between a routine out and a dropped ball in the gap. Speed and fielding rating matter big in extra innings.

8. Don’t Be Afraid to Bunt

Sometimes old-school tactics still work. A well-timed bunt with a fast runner can change the momentum, especially in extra innings with the runner-on-second rule. Drag bunts and squeezes still have their place—use them smartly.

9. Invest in the Right Players

Winning close games often depends on clutch performers. Whether you’re building your Diamond Dynasty squad or Franchise team, invest your stubs wisely. If you're looking to build up your roster, many players turn to options like buy MLB The Show 25 stubs to get the resources needed for key upgrades.

If you're wondering about the best place to buy stubs MLB The Show 25, many in the community recommend checking out U4N for its reliability and speed. Having the right players in your lineup can make all the difference when it’s time to deliver in big moments.

10. Stay Cool Under Pressure

This might sound basic, but staying composed during high-leverage situations can’t be overstated. Take your time between pitches, pause the game if you need to regroup, and don’t let frustration dictate your decisions. Confidence and composure often win clutch games more than pure skill.

Mastering these strategies won’t just help you win more clutch games—they’ll help you become a smarter, more complete player overall. Whether you're grinding ranked seasons or climbing through events, keeping your head in the game and your squad well-prepped is key to success in MLB The Show 25.